Menu
Your Cart
Welcome to
Cheese Secrets
Shop Now About Us
Quickview
Tortillions Cheese (100g)
Popular
Tortillions Cheese (100g)
Cheese Secrets - Tortillions Cheese (100g) Enjoyed by people of all ages, the Tortillons are strings of cheese that have been brine-cured an..
$5.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Black Lemon Gouda- Ruscello(100g)
Popular
Black Lemon Gouda- Ruscello(100g)
Black Lemon Gouda- Ruscello(100g)A special newcomer is the Ruscello Black Lemon, black in color, surprising and refreshing in taste. This product is e..
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g)
Popular
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g)
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g) Firm Cheese, Mild, Yellow with Red Peppers Ingredients: Milk, Salt, Colour, Calcium Chloride,..
$6.29
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
5 Brothers- Gunn's Hill (100g)
Popular
5 Brothers- Gunn's Hill (100g)
Cheese Secrets - 5 Brothers (100g) by Gunn's Hill Artisan Cheese- Woodstock, Ontario This is a hand-crafted washed rind cow's milk cheese that co..
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Popular
Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar- Cows Creamery  (100g) Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar has its roots from the Orkney Islands, north of Scotland. Aged ..
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
2 Year Old Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Popular
2 Year Old Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Cheddar – 2 Years Old- Cows Creamery (100g) The COWS CREAMERY Cheddar recipe has its roots from the Orkney Islands, which is north of Scotland.Th..
$6.29
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Olives Gordal (580ml)
Popular
Olives Gordal (580ml)
Cheese Secrets - Olives Gordal (580ml)Eating olive from the Gordal variety of olive tree. The name Gordal ("the fat one") is due to its shap..
$12.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Black Truffle Gouda (100g)
Popular
Black Truffle Gouda (100g)
Black Truffle Gouda (100g) Uniquely aromatic and often thought of as a cheese to be saved for special occasions. This cheese has a flavour that s..
$9.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
5 Brothers Smoked- Gunn's Hill (100g)
5 Brothers Smoked- Gunn's Hill (100g)
5 Brothers Smoked- Gunn's Hill Artisan Cheese (100g) This is a hand crafted cheese that combines traits from Gouda and another Swiss variety call..
$8.29
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
5 Brothers- Gunn's Hill (100g)
Popular
5 Brothers- Gunn's Hill (100g)
Cheese Secrets - 5 Brothers (100g) by Gunn's Hill Artisan Cheese- Woodstock, Ontario This is a hand-crafted washed rind cow's milk cheese that co..
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
BellaVitano Merlot Cheddar (100g)
Popular
BellaVitano Merlot Cheddar (100g)
BellaVitano Merlot Cheddar (100g) This delicious cheddar from Wisconsin is sure to please your favourite cheese lovers.  Great with fresh cr..
$8.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Guacamole Gouda- Amanti (100g)
Guacamole Gouda- Amanti (100g)
Guacamole Gouda- Amanti (100g) Daily Dairy’s newest Dutch Craft Cheese, Amanti Guacamole is the newest addition to the Amanti range of specialty ..
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g)
Popular
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g)
Colby with Hot Peppers- Thornloe Cheese (100g) Firm Cheese, Mild, Yellow with Red Peppers Ingredients: Milk, Salt, Colour, Calcium Chloride,..
$6.29
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Bleu D’Elizabeth- Québec (100g)
Bleu D’Elizabeth- Québec (100g)
Bleu D’Elizabeth (100g) Fromagerie du Presbytère - Bleu d’Élizabeth is a semi-soft cheese made from thermalized milk with interior mould. Its nat..
$8.89
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
Celtic Blue- Glengarry Fine Cheese (100g)
Celtic Blue- Glengarry Fine Cheese (100g)
Celtic Blue- Glengarry Fine Cheese (100g) Glengarry Fine Cheese - The Celtic Blue is a soft creamy blue cheese, with delicate blue veining a..
$8.99
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Quickview
2 Year Old Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Popular
2 Year Old Cheddar- Cows Creamery (100g)
Cheddar – 2 Years Old- Cows Creamery (100g) The COWS CREAMERY Cheddar recipe has its roots from the Orkney Islands, which is north of Scotland.Th..
$6.29
Add to Cart
Add to Wish List Compare this Product
Pick-up Your Order at Our Store in Niagara on the Lake!

Amazing Cheese and Charcuterie Boards!


Shop Now
$10 Next-day Delivery Within Niagara, St. Catharines, Welland, & Surrounding Areas

Discover Cheese Secrets

Our Cheese
Our Cheese
Deli- Fish Products
Deli- Fish Products
Anchovies
Anchovy Fillets - Parsley & Garlic
Caviar - Trio
Caviar Classic Siberian - Black
Caviar Gold - Farmed
All products
Deli- Prepacked
Deli- Prepacked
Boards & Platters
Boards & Platters
Charcuterie Platter- Prices starting from
Giftware
Giftware
Swissmar Cheese Picks (2.5") (3-Pack)
Swissmar Cheese Picks (2.5”)
Have Your Order Express Shipped Across Canada & USA!

Welcome to Cheese Secrets

Your family-run local artisan cheese & deli market!

The secret at Cheese Secrets is that we specialize in artisan cheeses from Canada, with new favourites coming in every week. We carry some very special international cheeses too, including Roquefort Carles, St. Agur and St. Andre from France, top quality Parmesan and Grana Padano from Italy, Cave Aged Gruyere from Switzerland and some delicious cheeses from the UK as well. Local charcuterie (Pingue - delish), relishes, mustards, jellies, olives, smoked salmon, freshly baked bread are all offered for your pleasure.

About Us

What our customers say

Xavier was a wonderful host as he spoke about the various types of cheeses and offered samples. The varieties are so unique and pack so much flavour. Very much worth a visit EVERY time you're in the area. I can't wait to be back. It was the highlight of our wine tour in NOTL.
- Vee R.
We had a complete class in customer service when we visited cheese secrets this spring the owner, who was working, was absolutely amazing. My family and I adore cheese and we had so much fun trying and buying, I would highly recommend stopping here.
- Rochelle F.
Wonderful place, great selection of some amazing cheese ! And they are very knowledgeable in what they sell !
- Amanda A.
Amazing cheese and the owner is so knowledgable and friendly. We visit every time we are in the area!
- Jessica L.
the owner is friendly and knowledgeable and a stop there is always a treat. If you havent already tried it, give the English Sticky Toffee Cheese a try, its divine!
- Elizabeth G.
With so many different cheeses to chose from, it can be a wonderful learning experience to let the the store persons guide you and help find what you are looking for.Xavier and Melanie are so knowledgeable about their products. Different selections every time and love sampling and learning about the unique characteristics of each variety. Stop by to find the perfect cheese for wine night!
- Kevin C.
Delicious cheeses & great customer care!
- Mandy K.
we visit this shop every year when we're at Niagara on the lake for our anniversary. Great customer service and amazing cheese!!
- Kathryn P.
Whenever I visit my parents in NOTL from LA, this is on my MUST DO list! They have unique cheeses and other gourmet goodies that I can’t find anywhere else! Plus, the owners are friendly and fun! 🙂
- Anna W.
Not only did we get to sample a lot of delicious varieties of cheeses but we learned a lot of interesting facts. Make this your first stop to build a cheese board and then go out and find the perfect wines to pair with them. My husband and I loved this place!
- Kelly B.
The variety of the most well chosen cheeses from a variety of sources. Xavier will explain them all to you. Shop there and you will keep returning! Simply the best new family run business in old town! Yum yum 😋
- Claudette Y.
This place is amazing, with Staff and Owners who are passionate about their products. Your palate will be blown away.
- Randall C.
Wonderful store! We came across Cheese Secrets in an old Bon Appetit magazine article while searching what to do in the area. I am so happy we stopped! The staff was very helpful and was nice enough to make recommendations and offer samples. We came home with several different kinds of very unique cheeses, unlike anything I have found at home in Ohio. My only complaint is that I don't live closer, we will definitely be going back on our next trip to Niagara on the Lake!
- Rachael L.
Every time I'm in town this is always on my to-do list! Great selection of cheeses and friendly knowledgeable staff. They also have preserves, crackers and cheese-ware to make your perfect cheese plate.
- Samantha S.