Menu
Your Cart
Welcome to
Cheese Secrets
Shop Now About Us
Tortillions Cheese (100g)
New Popular
Cheese Secrets - Tortillions Cheese (100g) Enjoyed by people of all ages, the Tortillons are strings of cheese that have been brine-cured an..
$5.99
5 Brothers Gunn's Hill (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Gunn's Hill 5 Brothers (100g) This is a hand crafted washed rind cow's milk cheese that combines traits from Gouda ..
$7.99
Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar (100g) Avonlea Clothbound Cheddar has its roots from the Orkney Islands, north of Scotland. Aged..
$7.99
2 Year Old Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Cheddar – 2 Years Old (100g) The COWS CREAMERY Cheddar recipe has its roots from the Orkney Islands, which is north o..
$6.29
Ruscello Black Lemon (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Ruscello Black Lemon (100g) A special newcomer is the Ruscello Black Lemon, black in color, surprising and refreshing in ta..
$7.99
Bellavitano Merlot Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Bellavitano Merlot Cheddar (100g) The only cheese from the United States currently in our repetoire.  This delicious c..
$8.99
Kozlik's Canadian Mustard (250ml)
New Popular
Kozlik's Canadian Mustard (250ml) Choose between Old Smokey, Green Peppercorn, Market Mustard, XXX Hot, Honey Mustard, Black Harp, Sweet..
$7.99
Colby with Hot Peppers (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Colby with Hot Peppers (100g) Firm Cheese Mild, Yellow with Red Peppers Ingredients: Milk, Salt, Colour, Calcium Chlor..
$6.29
Swissmar Cheese Picks (2.5") (3-Pack) Stainless steel 2.5”. 3-Pack..
$13.99
Swissmar Cheese Picks (2.5”) Stainless steel 2.5”. Choose between Moose, Mapleleaf, Fish, Cow, or Goat...
$4.99
Jesse Tree – Dried Chanterelles Mushrooms (20g) ..
$14.99
Jesse Tree – Dried Morel Mushrooms (14g) ..
$37.99
 Jesse Tree – Dried Porcini Mushrooms (42.5g)  ..
$13.99
Dried Mushrooms (Oyster & Shiitake) (42.5g)  Jesse Tree - Dried Oyster Mushrooms, Dried Shiitake Mushrooms...
$9.99
Cheese Secrets - Swissmar Semi Soft Cheese Cutter (9”) 9 inches, stainless steel ..
$21.99
Cheese Secrets - Swissmar Cheese Knives (7.5”) Slimline - 7.5 inches, stainless steel...
$9.99
5 Brothers Smoked Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - 5 Brothers Smoked Cheddar (100g) This is a hand crafted cheese that combines traits from Gouda and another Swiss variety ca..
$8.29
5 Brothers Gunn's Hill (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Gunn's Hill 5 Brothers (100g) This is a hand crafted washed rind cow's milk cheese that combines traits from Gouda ..
$7.99
Bellavitano Merlot Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Bellavitano Merlot Cheddar (100g) The only cheese from the United States currently in our repetoire.  This delicious c..
$8.99
Cheese Secrets - Amanti Guacamole (100g) Daily Dairy’s newest Dutch Craft Cheese, Amanti Guacamole is the newest addition to the Amant..
$7.99
Colby with Hot Peppers (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Colby with Hot Peppers (100g) Firm Cheese Mild, Yellow with Red Peppers Ingredients: Milk, Salt, Colour, Calcium Chlor..
$6.29
Cheese Secrets - Blue D’Elizabeth (100g) Fromageric du Presbytere - Bleu d’Élizabeth is a semi-soft cheese made from ther..
$8.99
Cheese Secrets - Celitic Blue (100g) Glengerry Fine Cheese - The Celtic Blue is a soft creamy blue cheese, with delicate blue veining a..
$8.99
2 Year Old Cheddar (100g)
Popular
Cheese Secrets - Cheddar – 2 Years Old (100g) The COWS CREAMERY Cheddar recipe has its roots from the Orkney Islands, which is north o..
$6.29
Cheese Secrets - Welch Cheddar (100g) Available in Black Bomber, Beechwood, or Red Storm. With its gently nutty texture and subtle..
$6.49
Valledoro Grissini - Gourmet Breadsticks (100g) Valledoro is led by the third generation of the Zubani family. From 1954, the company continues t..
$3.89
Cheese Secrets - Truffle Sheep’s Milk (100g) It´s a particular and different cheese made from sheep milk and pure truffles quali..
$9.99
Cheese Secrets - Triple Creme Brie (100g) Saint Andre is a triple crème cow's milk cheese produced in Coutances, in the Normandy ..
$7.99
Tracy’s Vidal Ice Wine Jelly (125ml) Did you know Vidal Icewine Jelly is one of two of Tracy's pure wine jellies? This Jelly is made of..
$13.99
Pick-up Your Order at Our Store in Niagara on the Lake!

Amazing Cheese and Charcuterie Boards!

$10 Next-day Delivery Within Niagara, St. Catharines, Welland, & Surrounding Areas
Have Your Order Express Shipped Across Canada & USA!

Welcome to Cheese Secrets

Your family-run local artisan cheese & deli market!

The secret at Cheese Secrets is that we specialize in artisan cheeses from Canada, with new favourites coming in every week. We carry some very special international cheeses too, including Roquefort Carles, St. Agur and St. Andre from France, top quality Parmesan and Grana Padano from Italy, Cave Aged Gruyere from Switzerland and some delicious cheeses from the UK as well. Local charcuterie (Pingue - delish), relishes, mustards, jellies, olives, smoked salmon, freshly baked bread are all offered for your pleasure.

About Us